Page Comparison Please Pick

[FITZ]

Redesigned index page for better usability and a cleaner look. What do you think?

old: http://www.oldedartmouth.com

new: http://www.oldedartmouth.com/nntest/nn4test3.htm

Thanks!

[redViper]

i cant see either. my browser freezes everytime i try to open it. :trout:

[gr8jay]

Well, the only difference I find in this is the color
But I think u should retain the menu .. i mean the older menu seems better. the new one looks plain ..

[Guig0]

I prefer the first one, the organization of the content is better.

Cool pages! Like them both :)

[LoungeActx]

to be honest i'm not a fan of the information residing in boxes so close together. a user might get confused with what to read first. it doesn't flow together very well. i would try to make it more lateral..then across if you know what i mean...

but outta the 2 choices i'd go with the first one.

[ADverseFX.com]

I think you should go with a redesign if you are looking for impact changinf the colors and a css isnt going to do it any justice the layout is hard to follow (2).

[SureShot]

I liked the first one best - nice work too - very proffesional loooking