Vote: Ribcage v Kitiara

[Kitiara]

Voting will now start for the line art battle between myself and Ribcage. All random posts that have nothing to do with battle will be deleted. Voting will be closed January the 20th or first contestant to 50 votes.

[Guig0]

They´re both great!

really loved the knight on ribcage´s but my vote goes to Kit, her dragon has more details and is a lil bit nicer. (specially now that ribcage removed the phil´s look on the dragon :P)

[ahmed]

yep.. they're both great, but kitiara's has more realistic colouring and such... my vote goes to her=):beam:

:A+:

[Starpromo]

i voted for ribcage 'cos i felt sorry for him...

no only kidding

i think thats its alot more bizzy and the knight is really good

but i would of also voted kit, if i was allowed.

[sintax321]

I voted ribcage. I thought his looked like a velvet painting, one of those ones that glow under a black light. Very sweet:cool:

[alethos]

Both entries are very well done.

Kit's is so detailed and I love the dragon's pose. Great work, Kit.

I voted for Ribcage, however. His entry is not quite as intricate as Kit's, but it is so dynamic and full of atmosphere that I had to go with it.

I must say this was a difficult vote (I was considering abstaining cuz it was so hard to decide). Excellent work, both of you.

-Al

[kode]

yeah!! they're both great!

but I've voted for Kit .. [the dragon is so cool]

excellent work! :smirk:

[DDD]

I go with ribcage, more action and I love the colors. The knight is cool.

man I wanna battle but I cannot find the time

[kaotic]

i voted for kit because of the transparency of the wings
lol i dont know why i thought that was the best feature
ho well
both good entrys:hat:

[andr.in]

Now that was a hard choice!
:-\ but I voted for Kit!
I like the transparency of the wings n' all!Oh and the look on the dragons face is good!
But the other one is awesome too! I like both of them!

[DDD]

DId they pick dragons as the theme?? What were the rules??

[Makaveli]

Originally posted by Ilyas

Line Art Battle everyone!!

Theme: Fantasy -- Phil the Dragon, the terrible White Knight Slayer
Programs: A pen, a piece of paper, A scanner, Flash (did I forget anything?)
Size: let's make it big, shall we? Somewhere around 800*600
Participants: Kit, Jubby, Playamarz, Ribcage, Majeye (?)
Due Date: 01-05-03 (tell me if it's too short, Jubby)



there you go 3d :)

oh and i voted for Kit, looks as if the dragon just finished EATING phil which i like...someone should match up Kits dragon with the Phil evil demon lord from Guig0's pixel art :) :) :P :P

[reverendflash]

I voted for Kitiara, simply on composition alone. The artwork was superb from both, I just thought that Kit's was more pleasing to the eye. Purely a subjective opinion.

Rev

[telekinesis]

I voted for Kit because her dragon is......

::dan puts on whigger attitude to piss off lost::

off the hook, fa sho, coming straight from the D-A-double N-Y, heezy fasheezy......

::dan puts on normal attitude::

only thing I would have not done is give the wings translucent, besides that the detail and line art skill just owns i tup, nice color usage too!

[eyeinfinitude]

wow both of these battle pieces are great, but I had to choose one and I went with ribcage's piece because it tells more of a story. Kit's piece is amazing, the detail and color are well implimented, but ribcage's piece was a bit more interesting. Great job both of you. =)

[Jubba]

I voted for Kit. Both entries were amazing tho. Again I'm sorry for not being able to enter. I finally get my computer back tomorrow. My friend's supplier kept messing up my order. Its funny cuz they never had a problem with this supplier in 5 months, but as soon as they started ordering stuff for me they started to get wrong orders.

Kit: I would still like to have a line art battle in the future. :) Similar theme... eventually. I'll start a new thread when I am ready...

[Kitiara]

I look forward to it, Jubba. :)

I've got a vague idea for a theme as well, although whether it's as good as yours... We'll have to compare and take it from there.

And thank you for the votes and comments everyone. :)

[pom]

:crazy: ****, that's very nice!!! Kit, I love your dragon, but it's too static compared to Ribcage's, I think. and there's the white Knight too :beam:

pom (-:

[flashermx]

I liked both. But, I voted for Ribcage. Ribcage's proportions were alot better. Kitiara's dragon would have gotton my vote except I felt the head was a liitle to small for that great deatailed body.:sigh:

[ribcage]

Thanks for the votes guys, I appreciate the feedback.=)

[mjULTRA]

Both were very good entries, and it was hard to decide. What a close battle it is so far. Apologies for my non-entry.

[ribcage]

Kit's kung-fu is very good, maybe I switch from
dragon fist to tiger's claw..:rambo: :)

[deeplybreathe]

Both of the entries are amazing. This is probably one of the closest battles I've seen yet.

Kit's dragon I believe is much more pleasing to the eye than the latter, thanks to the colors she used, and I did like the translucent wings. The detail was great.

However, I did vote for RibCage, simply because of his content. I think it was more creative than simply drawing a dragon. I definately think that the colors could have been a little better, but overall, an incredibly thought up piece.

Although who am I to judge? I wouldn't even come close to those! Great job both of you.


Matt

[Soul]

I voted for Kit, very realistic :beam:

- Soul :goatee:

[SureShot]

I too voted for Kitiara but it was a tough choice, no doubt.

Both designs were amazing, this is a great race for sure.

My reason for voting for kit's is because of the realistic look to it. I looks extreamly professional for sure. Not to say that Ribs didnt look pro - it's just I liked the colours in kit's more. Rib get's a thumbs up for the action scene though - very good work.

[sintax321]

I found the head on Kits to not fit the detail of the body.

I liked the action and the bright colors on Ribcage's work.

Both where amazing though;)

[pinx]

when i click on their names to see the results, it returns an address not found page.

[pinx]

ok it's there now. i voted ribcage. his had more depth and a theme going on. a much more involved picture. this is not to say that kitiara's drawing wasn't increadible.

[epinephrine]

I voted for ribcage. Both were very well done but I really liked the colors and intensity in ribcages piece. Still both are way better than anything I could ever do. Awesome job you guys.:beam:

[JoshClancy]

I voted for kit Im loving her style and detail. Nice job kit

[bwbm]

I voted for Kitiara...because the image seems more original.

[Makaveli]

lmao @ bwbm's footer!! LOOKIT THEM GO!!!

anyways, this battle is so close! time to use a cliche "Win or Lose, both contests put up a great fight and both are winners" or whatever they say.... C:-)

[hojo]

what a close battle. both are great. i voted for ribcage though, i thought the knight was blocking the flames from the dragon was awesome.

[calaway42]

ya the knight on ribcages was awesome but isnt this battle based on dragon? so my vote goes to kitiara because i think her dragon was more detailed

[lostinbeta]

Wow this is wayyy close!

[Guig0]

Long time no see a close match like that. Congrats ribcage and Kit!:A+:

[pom]

Originally posted by calaway42
ya the knight on ribcages was awesome but isnt this battle based on dragon? so my vote goes to kitiara because i think her dragon was more detailed Actually no, it's supposed to be Knight slayer, so... :smirk:

[lostinbeta]

No the theme was Dragons, but it was an option if you wanted to add a knight.

[pom]

Quoting myself:Theme: Fantasy -- Phil the Dragon, the terrible White Knight Slayer :beam:

[lostinbeta]

I remember reading the thread and it was stated that the knight was optional. But then again, I don't have the best memory. I still voted for Kit. GO KIT GO!!!!!

[roy r ruiz]

Good work both of you

[GloryBe]

great stuff from both,

voted for kit, I'm a big detail fan, and kit you had some great blending and detail work on your dragon.

[pom]

All right, battle closed! That battle was awesome, really. Congratulations to you both :) and bravo Kit. C:-)

[lostinbeta]

Incredibly close battle!!!!

Official Results:

Ribcage: 30
Kitiara: 32



Both were excellent entries!

[Makaveli]

rib: you put up a most valiant effort!! i dub thee knight ribcage!!!
kit: m'lady, as always your artistic brilliance has shown itself, congratulations

[Kitiara]

Whoa, this was <i>close</i>... :o

Thanks to everyone who voted on this battle (think it timed out yesterday). Many congratulations also go to Ribcage, who has been in the lead for the most part, with a most splendid entry. You are a very talented artist and it has been a pleasure to compete against you. :)

Here's to the next line art battle... :beam:

[sheep]

when i was a kid i played D&D *hands head in shame*.... but that picture with the dragon and the knight looks awfuly familiar...:q:

[Guig0]

i´m 26 and i play, and i´m proud of that!

not! :P

[sheep]

we gave up when everyone was dead

[ribcage]

Congratulations Kitiara!!

Awesome battle !
It was cool to get so much feedback as well, ..good forum.
Big fan of your art , Keep em coming.